CRANV1P1
ASLIB Cranfield Research Project: Factors Determining the Performance of Indexing Systems: VOLUME 1. Design, Part 1. Text
Formation of Index Languages
chapter
Cyril Cleverdon
Jack Mills
Michael Keen
Cranfield
An investigation supported by a grant to Aslib by the National Science Foundation.
Use, reproduction, or publication, in whole or in part, is permitted for any purpose of the United States Government.
- 82 -
aggregation of attributes, where a term is defined by a number of attributes, each of
which reflects a different principle of division of the genus which lies at the heart of
the definition, e.g. , Poiseuille flow may be defined as Compressible, viscous, laminar
flow between closely parallel planes - and each attribute reflects a different charac-
teristic of division for the genus Flow. So where the basic class was Boundary layer
flow, for example, related classes brought in by this programme would include Shear
flow, Separated flow, Viscous flow, etc.
(10) A/Z collateral: the rotated A/Z index of concepts has already been described.
This search was made first by examining the index to find the basic class (question
concept) and any other concepts containing it (i. e., consisting of the basic class with
further qualifications). Those which seemed likely to be relevant were now added to
the basic class. For example, to the basic class Axial compressor was added Axial
flow compressor blade since this included the basic class and seemed relevant. Or,
to Heat transfer would be added such concepts as Convective heat transfer rate, Sur-
face subjected to heat transfer, Laminar heat transfer distribution, etc. It may be
noted that most of these further classes represent non-generic hierarchical relations
of the basic class. Also, that most of the question concepts already consisted of two
or more words and that in many cases there would not be any more concepts contain-
ing the one sought; e.g., this was the case with Multistage compressor, Non-circular
cylinder, Dissociated stream.
For those concepts containing more than one word a 'second-level' search was
also made, in which each significant word (and any of its adjacent variant word forms)
was examined separately and further classes selected from the total body of concepts
containing it. For example, to Axial compressor would be added Axial inlet impeller;
to Surge line would be added Stall limit line and Surge. It should be stressed that these
selections were made in the context of a given complete question and might vary some-
what for the same concept if the context differed. For example, in a question on the
Surge line of an axial compressor, the 'second-level' for Axial compressor would
reject Compressor surge (although it wquld be relevant to the question as a whole) because
this approach was already covered by th'e programme for Surge line. Again, [OCRerr] may
be noted that many of these further classes represented non-generic hierarchical
relations; in addition, the combined first and second level searches generally included
those terms selected from generic hierarchies in searches (4), (7) and (9) which also
included the actual terms used in the basic concept.
(11) Residual hierarchical linkage. The A/Z collateral searches, although providing
a large number of non-generic and generic hierarchical linkages, were restricted to
those which included one or more of the terms actually used in the question. This
still left a number of possibly helpful classes excluded. They could be divided into
two groups: firstly all those from the non-generic hierarchies which appeared in the
schedules where the question concept (the basic class) was located, but which failed
to include the actual question term or terms (in which case the A/Z collateral would
have disclosed them. ) It was a simple matter to establish these, by scanning the
various facets subordinated to a given concept, or adjacent to it.
Secondly, all related classes not already disclosed by the hierarchical relations
of the ten searches described. A number of these were already provided for in the
schedules, by references; e.g., Surface combustion (D66) see also Ablation; Vaneless
diffuser (in compressors) (F84) see also Ducts; Compressor surge see also Rotating
stall; Mass flow fluctuation (U44) see also Sound waves.