CRANV2
Aslib Cranfield Research Project: Factors Determining the Performance of Indexing Systems: Volume 2
Main test results
chapter
Cyril Cleverdon
Michael Keen
Cranfield
An investigation supported by a grant to Aslib by the National Science Foundation.
Use, reproduction, or publication, in whole or in part, is permitted for any purpose of the United States Government.
- 138 -
FIGURE 4. 513T
Index Language I. 6. a (S, T. Synonyms, Quasi-synonyms, Word forms. Coordination
Exhaustivity of Indexing 3
Search Hale C
Document Relevance 1 - 4
Number of Documents in Collection 1,400
Number of Questinns 20 (Subset 6)
Number of Relevant Documents see table
Generality Number see table
Coord- Documents
ination Relevant Generality Retrieved Recall Precision Fallout
Level Document s Number Rel. Non-rel. Ratio Ratio Ratio x y z
1 147 5,3 140 (-)
2 147 95.2% (-) (.) 20
5.3 113 0
3,323* 20
3 119 76.9% 3.3[OCRerr]* 20 13"
5.0 ii.93o[OCRerr]
66 1,544 57.1% 20
4.2% 6.519% 17 17 17
4 94 4.8 38 299 40.4% 11.3% II 14
5 14
43 1.533%
4.4 12 33
6 21 27.9% 26.7% 7
5.0 2 0.338% 6 7
2 9.5% 50.0% 0.046% I 3 3
FIGURE 4: 514T
Index Language I.l.a (S.T. Natural language. Coordination)
Exhaostivity of Indexing 3
Search Rule D
Document Relevance 1 - 4
Number of Documents in Collection1,400
Number of Questions 29 (Subset 6)
Number of Relevant Documents see table
Generality Number see table
Coord- Document s
ination Relevant Generality Retrieved Recall Precision Fallout
Level Documents Number Ret. Non-rel. R at io R at io R at io x y z
1 147 5.3 97
2 2,213 66.0%
147 4.5% 20 20
5.3 7.945% 20
73 653
3 119 49.7% 10.1% 20 20
5.0 42 163 35.3% 20.5% 2.344% 20
0.688% 15 17 17
4 94 4.8 20 14
5 21.3%
43 58.8% 8
4.4 14 14
7 4 16.3% 0.072%
6 21 63.6% 2 7
5.0 7
1 2 0.041%
4.8% 33.3% 0.048% I 3 3
FIGURE 4. 515T
Index Language 1.6.a (SmT. Synonyms, Quasi-synonyms, Word forms.
Exhaustivity of Indexing 3
Search Rule D
Document Relevance 1 - 4
Number of Documents in Collection 1,400
Number of Questions 20 (Subset 6}
Number of Relevant Documents see table
Coordination}
Coord-
ination Relevant Generality Documents Recall Precision Fallout x y z
Level Documents Number Retrieved
Hel, Non-rel. Ratio Ratio Ratio
1 147 5.3 102
2 147 2,668 69.4% 3.7% 20
5.3 20 20
81 791 9.579%
3 119 55.1% 9.3%
5.0 48 20
189 2.840% 20 20
40.3% 20.3% 0. 798% 15 17 17
4 94 4.8 25
5 21
43 4.4 26.6% 54.3% 11
10 14 14
6 23.3% O. 108%
6 21 62.5%
5.0 0. 061% 4 7 7
1 2 4.8% 33.3% 0. 048% 1 3 3