CRANV2
Aslib Cranfield Research Project: Factors Determining the Performance of Indexing Systems: Volume 2
Main test results
chapter
Cyril Cleverdon
Michael Keen
Cranfield
An investigation supported by a grant to Aslib by the National Science Foundation.
Use, reproduction, or publication, in whole or in part, is permitted for any purpose of the United States Government.
- 186 -
Section 8 Abstracts and Titles
This section does not introduce any new index language device,
since it deals with searches carried out on the abstracts and titles
of the 200 document collection. As such it represents a variation
in exhaustivity of indexing, and also, in some cases, different
concept indexing to that done by the project staff. The searches
are done first in single term natural language and then with
word forms confounded.
Figures 4.900T and 4.901T present the results of searches
on the titles only, and Figures 4.902T and 4.903T present the results
obtained with titles and abstracts. Figure 4.904P is a plot of the
four tables.
In order to make a comparison from the viewpoint of exhaustivity,
Figures 4.910T and 4.911T present the results of Index Language
1.3.a (word forms) at exhaustivity levels of 2 and 1, on the 200
document collection. Plot 4.912P now gives the performance curves for
the three levels of exhaustivity with the project indexing, for the
search on titles alone and for the search on titles and abstracts.
We were able to do this series of tests by having a print out
of a concordance of the titles and abstracts of the 200 documents.
This was prepared with the SMART programme, and we are indebted
to Prof. Salton for making it available
4. 900T
4. 901T
4. 902T
4.903T
4. 904P
4.910T
4.911T
4.912P
LIST OF FIGURES
Index
Language
IV.l.a
IV.2.a
IV. 3.a
IV.4.a
IV.1 .a
IV.2.a
IV.3.a
IV.4.a
1.3.a
1.3.a
IV. 2.a
IV.4.a
1.3.a
1.3.a
1.3.a
Exhaust {vity
2
1
3
2
1
No. of Question Document
Questions Subset Collection
42 2 200
42 2 200
42 2 200
42 2 2OO
42 2 200
42 2 200
42 2 200
42 2 200
Plot s
4.900T
4.901T
4.902T
4.903T
4. 901T
4.903T
4.201T
4.910T
4.911T