IRS13
Scientific Report No. IRS-13 Information Storage and Retrieval
Test Environment
chapter
E. M. Keen
Harvard University
Gerard Salton
Use, reproduction, or publication, in whole or in part, is permitted for any purpose of the United States Government.
these additional concept numbers sometimes have the effect of a recall device1
and sometimes that of a precision device. Fig. 7 gives an example of the
use of concon, where the fir[OCRerr]t order matches of type A, and all second order
matches, are recall devices because four additional matches between request
and document are made possible by the use of concon. The one first order
match of type B acts as a precision device because "cylinder" was already
matched in request and document, but the concon pair "Unit + cylinder" gives
added weight to "cylinder" in the document, and this in turn gives greater
prominence to the match on "cylinder" in the final request/document matching
correlation.
The case of the phrase dictionary is also complex. Phrases normally
act as a precision device of coordination, when the phrases recognized are
used to completely replace all occurrences of the component concepts which
do not meet the phrase criteria individually. When phrase identifiers are
merely added to existing identifiers, phrases may act as a precision device
by virtue of the weighting effect already discussed. In a few circumstances,
phrases also act as a recall device. The weighting effect acts as a precision
device only when the concepts being added to the document increase the weight
of some, and not all, of the identifiers already in the document; this is,
in general, the case with SMART.
This disc'[OCRerr]ssion of devices shows that the clear-cut distinction
between recall and precision devices is not easy to preserve, and its usefulness
is probably now somewhat limited. This is particularly true because the effect
of the various dictionaries is only detected in the performance measures if a
certain type of cut-off is applied, namely, a cut-off that directly uses the