IRS13
Scientific Report No. IRS-13 Information Storage and Retrieval
An Analysis of the Documentation Requests
chapter
E. M. Keen
Harvard University
Gerard Salton
Use, reproduction, or publication, in whole or in part, is permitted for any purpose of the United States Government.
x-38
thesaurus, then a sjn[OCRerr]le automatic choice could be made by the system.
Using the Abstract Stem versus Abstract Thesaurus result, Figure 22 shows
that more of the factors of generality, length or concept frequency are
correlated with either dictionary, and even the requests made up by the
two preparers do not markedly prefer particular dictionaries. Other
criteria may be discovered to aid such a pre-aearch eboice, [OCRerr]d if a perfect
choice were achieved the result would be as given in Figure 23, where the
curve based on choice of the best dictionary is seen to be better than use
of either dictionary exclusively.
The possibility of achieving a satisfactory automatic subject re-
cognition is considered in an extensive analysis performed by J. O'Connor
f7]. It seems certain that some loss of performance due to inability to
correctly recognize and match with ideas asked for in requests will be
experienced unless very Sophisticated procedures can be developed. However,
failure in matching occurs also in manual systems due both to errors and
inability to cope with the tasks of manual indexing and vocabulary control;
it is thus by no means certain that automatic systems will in practi[OCRerr]e prove
inferior.