ISR11
Scientific Report No. ISR-11 Information Storage and Retrieval
Design Consideration for Time Shared Automatic Documentation Centers
chapter
M. E. Lesk
Harvard University
Gerard Salton
Use, reproduction, or publication, in whole or in part, is permitted for any purpose of the United States Government.
X-2
to operational situations and make future plans. The following discussion
is intended to be of general interest, although its specific proposals
refer to the computing equipment (IBM SYSTEM 3&/67) to be available at
Cornell and/or Harvard Universities in the near future.
2. Principles
The first question that must be raised about any information retrieval
system is that of purpose. For [OCRerr]Yhat users is the system to be designed,
and what service is to be offered to them ? The SMART system has been an
exclusively experimental system, whose user population is a small group of
researchers at the Harvard Computation Center and whose function is to
evaluate retrieval algorithms. It should become a system which provides
practical information retrieval services for a user group of working
researchers.
This does not imply that no further work is to be done on small-scale
experimental systems. There is much to be learned about retrieval procedures
through detailed analysis of small examples[OCRerr]; new methods and systems will
always be proposed that can be tried out economically on small subcollec-
tions. However, work on large collections irnlst also begin.
Operating systems are subject to various difficulties that must not be
faced in experimental, small-scale systems. Experimental systems are used
to investigate the details of retrieval methods in intensively analyzed
document collections. This work remains valid, and in fact cannot be
done in large-scale systems. However, the problems of user interaction, of
time and presentation problems, of economics of use, of system maintenance,