ISR11
Scientific Report No. ISR-11 Information Storage and Retrieval
Design Consideration for Time Shared Automatic Documentation Centers
chapter
M. E. Lesk
Harvard University
Gerard Salton
Use, reproduction, or publication, in whole or in part, is permitted for any purpose of the United States Government.
x-8
a request which can be answered correctly. The computer is a better judge
of its own flaws and requirements than a user who has not seen the system
before. It may be expected, then, that in case a) iterative retrieval
based upon feedback will be superior to rephrasing by any but the most
experienced users. In cases b) and c), however, where parts of the question
as stated are actually misleading and where more is required than simply
adjusting the style of writing of the user, feedback may be expected to be
less useful. In case c) clearly a complete rewriting of the question is
called for. The computer might nevertheless assist in this rewriting by
displaying, upon request, portions of the thesauri and/or hierarchy `in the
region being studied.
The above outline should be c[OCRerr]m[OCRerr]on to virtually all requests submitted
to the retrieval system. Some additional features might be needed frequently.
For example, a method of arbitrarily marking certain documents to prevent
their retrieval will be necessary. The most obvious examples of this need
arise in the case of a multi-lingual document collection where users will
wish to specify the languages that they can read, or in the case of a
partially classified collection in which users without the appropriate
security clearance zinist be denied access to certain documents. Suen an
exclusion feature can also be used positively, however. Users might wish
to request only current documents, for example. Furthezi[OCRerr]ore, someone who
is totally unfamiliar with a field might wish to begin by requesting only
review articles and books. There may well be a demand by students for
textbooks or other more elementary treatments of a subject.
Another specialized facility that would often be used is a set of
special-purpose dictionaries. In fields with rapidly changing vocabulary,