MONO91
NIST Monograph 91: Automatic Indexing: A State-of-the-Art Report
Other Potentially Related Research
chapter
Mary Elizabeth Stevens
National Bureau of Standards
6.2.1 Devices to Display Associations: EDIAC
The interest aroused among some documentalists by the provocative idea of a t!Memex!!
to record and display associations between ideas as proposed by Bush in 1945 ([93]) led to
specific attempts at Documentation, Inc. in the 1950's to develop a device which would
incorporate at least the associations between indexing terms assigned to documents and
between documents with respect to their sharing of common indexing terms (1954 [157],
1956 [155, 156]). The first approach to this objective, as reported by Taube, was the idea
of a manual dictionary of terms arranged in alphabetical order, with a "page" reserved for
each and every indexing term used for any document in the collection. On each page would
be listed all other terms that had co-occurred with that term in the indexing of one or more
documents. Another idea was to display associations of terms used in a collection through
the "superimposition of dedicated positions in a set of cards or plates. . . 1/
Subsequently, an actual device to demonstrate a system for display of term-term,
term-document, and document-document associations, was built under an Office of Naval
Research contract. 2/ The demonstration model contained a vocabulary of 250 terms which
had been used in various combinations to index 100 reports. Interconnections in an elec-
trical network provided the associational linkages. A display panel was provided with
symbol-indicators which could be lighted up to identify particular terms and particular
report numbers.
This EDIAC device (for Electronic Display of[OCRerr]Indexing Association and Content) was
intended for use both in guiding an indexer to either the extension or refinement of his
initial choice of indexing terms and in assisting the searcher. It was claimed that the
operation of such a device would be extremely simple. Thus:
"For the index question the searcher selects any term in which he is interested
and applies a voltage. He is told instantly the number of the repqrts dealing with
that subject. Putting voltage in at any term also lights all other terms associated
with the first term. .. " 3/
A later analog device, ACORN, will be discussed below in connection with the work
of Giuliano and associates, at Arthur D. Little, Inc.
6.2.2 Statistical Association Factors - Stiles
The name of H. Edmund Stiles, like those of Luhn, Baxendale, Maron, Swanson,
Edmundson and Wyllys, is generally associated with pioneering innovations in those areas
of mechanized documentation which are directly related to the use of high-speed computer
capabilities. While Stiles! work has been directed primarily to problems of search
prescription formulation and renegotiation based on the results of preliminary search, he
has specifically recognized that the use of statistical word association techniques in
searching operations can provide a logical corollary to automatic indexing procedures.
Thus:
1/
2/
3/
Taube et al, 1954 [599], p. 102.
It is described and illustrated in Taube et al, 1956 [599], p. 63 ff.
Documentation, Inc. 1956 [156], p. 7.
119